Read This Before You Buy A New Pillow

Dr Russell Jensen, Chiropractor (AHPRA CHI0001927257), is the principal chiropractor at Southside Spine and Sport in Bicton. He has been practising since 2015 and trained in Integrative Diagnosis in the United States, with a particular interest in nerve entrapment conditions.


Quick Facts

  • Move your pillow before you buy a new one. On your back, try sliding it down so it supports your neck and your chin sits comfortably without tucking toward your chest.
  • A pillow that works on your side can be too high on your back. On your side, aim for enough height to keep your head in line with your spine.
  • Use a second pillow where you need it. Try one under your knees if your lower back feels arched on your back, or between your knees if you tend to roll forward on your side.
  • Medium-firm is a reasonable starting point. In one trial, people with chronic lower back pain did better on a medium-firm mattress than a firm one.
  • Get persistent or worsening pain assessed. If your morning pain keeps getting worse or you notice numbness or weakness, get it checked.

Most mornings, before I do much else, I sit on the couch for five or ten minutes. Right through my lower thoracic spine, there's a stiffness that some days is mild and some days is quite painful. It eases once I've moved and warmed up. From the patients I have spoken to over the years, so many people know the feeling.

I'm also a back sleeper. I'd prefer to sleep on my side, but nothing I've tried has kept me there through the night.


Why I Started Digging For More Information on Sleep Position

I’m a professional who knows a great deal already about good sleep posture for airway patency and spinal health. But I wanted to know more and if my sleep position or pillow setup had anything to do with my situation. What I found first was a run of generic videos and articles that told me almost nothing useful.

Then I found a video from Conor Harris, a strength and conditioning coach. It was the first video that had some new information that was safe to try that I hadn’t heard before.

If you're after a more general starting point on pillows, I’ve written a guide to choosing one: How to Buy the Right Pillow: A Chiropractor's Guide

The Problem With Most Sleep Position Advice

Mattress and pillow advice online is a minefield. I spend my working life trying to separate evidence from confident-sounding opinions of influencers. Often good, actionable information is hard to draw out of research that most patients have probably already tried.

In recent times, where safe and low stakes, I have turned to professionals like myself that have specific, lesser known training backgrounds that havn’t quite made it to journal articles, yet.
Often the advice coming from these people helps the patients who aren’t getting much relief with the mainstream advice but are too scared to try anything else without input from a professional.

So that’s what has lead me to Conor Harris's information specifically. It isn't peer-reviewed science. In my own experience with it, it's been actionable, low risk to try and quite helpful for me personally.

The Tweak That Changed The Game For Me

Here's the single tweak that changed how I think about pillows.

A pillow's job isn't to cushion your head. It's to support your neck to correctly position your head.

That sounds small, but it isn't. I noticed one of my own pillows was great when I was side sleeping. But whenever I rolled onto my back the pillow cranked my head forward and closed my airway.

For context, I have mild sleep apnea, that gets worse as I move deeper into sleep because the muscle tone of my throat and upper airway, relaxes and narrows.


Setting Up For Back Sleeping

If you're a back sleeper, try these steps.

  1. Reposition your pillow. Slide it down so it supports your neck, until your chin points slightly up rather than tucking toward your chest. This opens the airway.

  2. Pillow under the knees. If your lower back tends to feel arched or tight, propping your thighs up to tilt the pelvis back can help. If you tend more toward a rounded, forward-shoulder posture, you may not want that same change, since you likely need to keep more curve through your lower back, not less.

  3. Favour a firmer mattress over a very soft one, mainly so you don't sink in a way that pulls your pelvis and ribs out of a stable relationship with each other overnight.

Quick Research note: A 2003 randomised controlled trial published in The Lancet found that people with chronic lower back pain did better on a medium-firm mattress than a firm one. And a 2017 study using overnight sleep studies found that mildly elevating the head of the bed reduced sleep apnea severity by around 31 percent on average.

Setting Up For Side Sleeping

Generally speaking, if I am asked what position is best for sleeping, not knowing anything else about a person, I recommend side sleeping first.

  1. Get your pillow height right. It should be thick enough that your neck stays neutral with your spine instead of leaning toward the mattress or lifting away from it.

  2. A small rolled towel under your waist. This can help if you notice yourself side sagging toward the mattress through the night or are waking up with lower thoracic pain in the morning.

  3. Pillow between your knees. Honestly, wherever is most comfortable for you, I prefer between the knees. It just needs to prevent you trying to roll forward or backward.

  4. A slight bend through your hips and knees - keeps the muscles of your legs from being tensioned and potentially pulling on your pelvis.


What About Mouth Taping?

Mouth taping to encourage nasal breathing is a common recommendation and some people find it helpful. A 2025 systematic review of the available studies found mixed evidence and flagged a risk of restricted breathing in people with any nasal obstruction. Do not try this if you have any nasal congestion or obstruction or have been diagnosed sleep condition without discussing it with your GP first.

Try This Simple Breathing Check

Try it during the day, sitting comfortably:

Breathe in gently through your nose for about two seconds, then out through your nose for about two seconds.

After that exhale, pause and see how long you can comfortably hold before you feel the first real urge to breathe again. Not a strained hold, just the first natural prompt.

If it’s quite short, it's not something to panic about, but it may be worth mentioning to your GP and ask about a Sleep Study to investigate your breathing at night.

If it's comfortably long, that's a reasonable sign your nasal breathing capacity is solid.

The Bottom Line

I don't think there's a single perfect sleep position that works for everyone, and I'd be wary of anyone who tells you there is.

If your pain persists, worsens, or comes with anything unusual (numbness, weakness, pain that wakes you from sleep repeatedly, or pain that doesn't ease at all through the day), that's worth having assessed properly rather than adjusting pillows indefinitely.


Frequently Asked Questions

Does sleep position actually affect back pain?


In my experience, yes, though the effect varies a lot between people. Position mainly affects the load and curvature through your spine overnight, which can influence morning stiffness, though other factors (mattress support, general activity levels, and underlying conditions) play a role too.

Is it better to sleep on your back or your side?


There's no single answer that applies to everyone. Side sleeping tends to make it easier to keep the spine in a neutral position, but a well set up back sleeping position can also work well, particularly with the right pillow placement.

Is mouth taping safe for everyone?


No. It should not be used by anyone with nasal obstruction, congestion, or a diagnosed breathing condition without speaking to their GP first, since it carries a real risk of restricting airflow in those situations.

How long does it take to notice a difference from changing sleep position?


It varies. Some people notice a change within a few nights, others take longer as their body adjusts to a new position. Give any change a genuine trial of at least a week or two before deciding whether it's helping.

Should I see someone about ongoing morning stiffness or back pain?


If it's persistent, worsening, or comes with other symptoms like numbness or weakness, it's worth having assessed as part of a proper evaluation rather than trying to solve it through sleep setup alone.

If your morning stiffness or back pain has been sticking around, a proper assessment can help work out what's actually driving it. As part of an assessment, we look at movement, load, and where it's safe to start, not just your sleep setup.


Or call us on 08 6317 9897


Reviewed by Dr Russell Jensen, Chiropractor, AHPRA CHI0001927257.

Next
Next

I Was Going to Write A Blog About Flexibility. Then I Realised I Needed to Work on My Own.